Resizable screen capture

[LonM]

@pesala I wouldn't say overkill. I'd call it polish. In most other programs where you can make a rectangular selection, the selection box is sizeable after being created. I think it makes sense to include here.

Now this is absolutely a low-priority issue for me, and I'm always torn as to whether I should vote on FRs that are polish rather than something brand new and shiny.

[bimlas]

@pesala I'm using FastStone Image Viewer but didn't know about the screen capturing stuff, thanks for the link. A bit better solution is ShareX which works on *nix systems too.

Anyway: feature requests are about adding new behavioural "extensions" OR imporving current ones. I think most of the users don't want to install additional software just to take a screenshot from a website: Vivaldi has the ability to take screenshots, but it has a very basic knowledge. This FR is about making it more usefull.

To be frank, it has to be an "upper limit" of the feature, for example I can imagine that users would like to upload the screenshot to Imgur from the menu, or draw on it, make it grayscale and so on. So basically I understand your opinion and I'm agree with it, but this feature is small enough to implement.

[Catweazle]

It is good that Vivaldi includes a screen capture function, but as always happens with extensions or screenshot functions in a browser, its use is limited to always using it in combination with the browser.
For this reason, just like @Pesala, I prefer a desktop grabber, much more complete and with more functionality than any Vivaldi function can have.
I use ShareX, an Open Source program, which allows me not only to do all kinds of image captures, but also in video, gif, QR code and text (OCR), apart from including a complete editor and the ability to upload the captures to the corresponding hosts and imagesharer.

[Pesala]

@lonm said in Resizable screen capture:

I'm always torn as to whether I should vote on FRs that are polish rather than something brand new and shiny

It depends on a couple of factors:

• How much work would it take? If probably very little, then the polish is worthwhile. For example: Show Current Version on Updates Tab. It is not necessary as one can find the info easily on Help, About.
• How easy is it to work around? In this case, very easy. Either take more care the first time, or select the area again (one does not even have to cancel the current selection). If one needs pixel level precision, then open the screen capture in an image program to crop it, or use aforesaid dedicated programs.

[Seasonly]

I don't understand how screencapture is so depreciated. Today, when we search something, we assume to search media with media. I mean, the bar address allows to search with words but we can also search by others medias like images or even sounds... If sounds seems a far idea, the image search is not or shouldn't be. And that's why the tool should be so handy and transparent to use as the others : for instance, resizing an area avoids to precisely and boringly to manipulate your mouse or the screen capture interface (which is not so easy into Vivaldi's solution) ; I even think that the screen capture button should appear into the bar address. And according to this, the screen capture should call image search engine directly, probably this should be parametered to know which is the user's image search engine.

That's why I don't think that the screen capture feature is a low-priority problem. And if you need to use screencapture to illustrate something, you don't need a basic tool. In fact, considering the screen capture like this, means that the current vivaldi screen capture feature is useless : so few handy for image searching, so few useful for quoting that you prefer downloading an extension.

[Pesala]

@seasonly On a daily basis I post simple screen shots like the one in this thread.

If I want to capture a long web page, however, Vivaldi's screen capture is much faster and more reliable than FastStone, although it is limited to 30,000 pixels.

[Seasonly]

@pesala

And what about privacy information about your bookmarks without blurring for instance ? I mean that's all this stuff, blurring, arrows... is not a luxe today, it's needed to point precisely what is the aim of the screen capture image, without to spread over internet your personal information.

When I make images for my messages, (the english is not my native language) the image quoted with arrows, flashing rectangle is an helpful tool to explain myself.
Screen capture shouldn' be a leak for security even for the beginner users.

Should you have a look to the new opera screencapture tool ?

For the screen capture of all the page, indeed vivaldi is handy, I even wonder if it is not the main aim of the screen capture development into vivaldi's team : the selection part is not placed in foreground whereas it's seems to me more useful than the all-page menu.

[S_Paternotte]

I use the screen capture function a lot and I would definitely like to be able to resize the capture area. After all, any next attempt is (again) only as good as one can be using the mouse.
To make things perfect it is very important to also allow using the keyboard cursor keys (up, down, left, right) to enable pixel perfect (re) sizing.

[Pesala]

@Seasonly said in Resizable screen capture:

And what about privacy information about your bookmarks without blurring for instance ?

FastStone Capture has all of the tools that anyone would need for that. I don't think Vivaldi needs to add any more bloat to the feature. It is easy enough to edit images in IrfanView, or whatever if you don't have a decent screen capture program for your OS.

[S_Paternotte]

@Pesala Your viewpoint is perfectly clear, as it has been throughout this thread.
Still, that does not have to be the final word, does it?

I'm chiming in here to expresss support for a hopefully small , but important enhancement that I miss on a weekly basis and every time it makes me feel sad to have to switch over to my favourite screen capture apps SniPaste or PicPick.

[Seasonly]

@Pesala
Thanks for sharing this link. But I don't think this is the Vivaldi asset to get another extern program for a such basic function. I use Gimp and print screen button now.

I want to add that what I expect for this screencapture tool is only the image equivalent of text quotation.
At least for explaining ourself into this forum. When we're dealing with letters, we can select what we want to share, delete parts we don't. A basic screen capture tool should do the same for image with special needs for image : I want only a part of the image, I want to delete into this this line, to blur this other part, and make a flashing rectangle or arrow with annotation to show what i want to focus on.

But this true if I want to make image composition, I would use then gimp.

[LonM]

This feature is now Done