How will Vivaldi deal with Google's Manifest V3?
-
@Catweazle Since that's ancient, and since Adguard supports what he's talking about, I think that would be the better choice.
-
@rseiler, yes, AdGuard is Mv3, like also uBOL, the block ads, but not so sure if they do it also with trackers, because it is most what is Googles business model. In tests, in adblocking and trackerblocking, the Vivaldi blocker has way better results as, at least, uBOL, except the anti adblock spoofing.
Necause of this, I don't not longer trust the Chrome Store in Privacy related extensions abd think that Vivaldi need to be with own functions mostly independient of the Chrome Store.
I think that Vivaldi with its ibuild blocker is on the right way, but they is still room of improvement. In other extensions currently show that most extensions in the Chrome Store are already redundant in Vivaldi because of its inbuild features.With AdGuard I see only the way of the desktop app, not the extension, but it is paid proprietary soft and only offers a 14 day free trial.
>Laptop ACER, AMD Ryzen, GPU AMD Radeon RAM 16GB, SSD 512GB -Win11 Home 64 v24H2| Vivaldi last stable|
-
@Catweazle Fodder to think about in the coming months, that's for sure. For anyone curious, this is what it uses (in the case of tracking, it appears to be a hybrid approach):
https://adguard.com/kb/general/ad-filtering/adguard-filters
I'm more concerned about their ongoing battle with Google to try to get them to accept some method of allowing them to update filters between updating the extension itself. They were winning that battle for a while, but right now, for instance, here are the last update dates:
Base filter: Feb 27
Tracking: Mar 4
Social: Mar 4
Annoyances: Mar 4
Security: Mar 5Without solving that, it's a no-go. The Windows proxy version wouldn't have that problem.
-
Said:
AdGuard is Mv3, like also uBOL, the block ads, but not so sure if they do it also with trackers…..
-
Said:
here are the last update dates:
Base filter: Feb 27
Tracking: Mar 4
Social: Mar 4
Annoyances: Mar 4
Security: Mar 5
Without solving that, it's a no-go.
Giving those dates is as ridiculous, if not more so, as when users claim that Vivaldi is not on the same version as Chrome, and are therefore grossly and horribly exposed.
-
@barbudo2005 I didn't know that updated filters were irrelevant. One less thing to worry about! (In case it's unclear, this is sarcasm.)
-
@m-e said in How will Vivaldi deal with Google's Manifest V3?:
I hated it how Firefox treated their add on community
You mean like when they switch to the one extension engine and broke well over half of all Firefox compatible extensions because they dropped the BOMB and told no one before hand?
-
@barbudo2005, Vivaldi isn't certainly on the same Chrome version, except for the security patches, because the Vivaldi team can't release a new version at the same day as a new Chromium release, it need a lot of work before, way more as only patching the Vivaldi logo on Chromium as is. But also far away from outdated and insecure.
https://yngve.vivaldi.net/sooo-you-say-you-want-to-maintain-a-chromium-fork/
>Laptop ACER, AMD Ryzen, GPU AMD Radeon RAM 16GB, SSD 512GB -Win11 Home 64 v24H2| Vivaldi last stable|
-
Take care of this post, so you don't keep disqualifying uBOL or Adguard gratuitously, things that only come out of your imagination.
AdGuard is Mv3, like also uBOL, the block ads, but not so sure if they do it also with trackers…..
-
The Gorhill's opinion about those sites that measure the efficiency of adblockers:
-
@barbudo2005, I never said anything against uBO, but Mv3 uBOL respect tracking.
-
Manifest V2 in Vivaldi, when does it stop working?
How do you plan to continue releasing updates for the browser, if, soon, there will be a transition to extensions for Chrome (Chromium) on Manifest V3? -
@kirill1996 said in Manifest V2 in Vivaldi, when does it stop working?:
Manifest V2 in Vivaldi, when does it stop working?
How do you plan to continue releasing updates for the browser, if, soon, there will be a transition to extensions for Chrome (Chromium) on Manifest V3?Please see https://forum.vivaldi.net/topic/93057/how-will-vivaldi-deal-with-google-s-manifest-v3/
-
@kirill1996 End is in June 2025.
There is no chance to extend this for Vivaldi dev team._bug hunter · Volunteer helper · Sopranos tester · Language DE,EN · ♀👵
Known old dragon lady: Gwen aka Dr. Gwen Agon aka GwenDragon aka DoctorGTesting
Linux Debian 12 KDE X11 / Windows 11 Pro
Intel i5-7400 / NVidia GT 710 -
@DoctorG said in Manifest V2 in Vivaldi, when does it stop working?:
There is no chance to extend this for Vivaldi dev team.
Brave said they would support it.
Why can't they copy code from Github to Vivaldi, yours? -
@kirill1996 said in Manifest V2 in Vivaldi, when does it stop working?:
Brave said they would support it.
Why can't they copy code from Github to Vivaldi, yours?I have no knowledge why this can not be added.
-
@DoctorG said in Manifest V2 in Vivaldi, when does it stop working?:
@kirill1996 End is in June 2025.
There is no chance to extend this for Vivaldi dev team.I'm sorry, but this sounds a bit misleading. Of course there is a chance that Vivaldi could extend support for MV2, similar to Brave, Opera and Firefox. The question is, do they WANT to do this or not?
-
@DoctorG Probably not that promptly due to Vivaldi using the extended stable channel of Chromium. I bet more like in August for us.
-
Just to clarify, Firefox uses another core so it is not affected by the change between MV2 and MV3.
-
Just to clarify, Vivaldi is not willing, does not want, is not interested, is not in the mood, is not willing to spend those scarce human resources forever, let's see how I put it so that it is well understood and once and for all.
